Short answer: A first flexible withdrawal from a pension is often taxed on an emergency code that treats it as if you'll receive it every month. You can reclaim the overpayment during the year with an HMRC form, or through Self Assessment after the year ends.
Why it happens
Providers without an up-to-date code for you use an emergency month-one basis. A single £20,000 taxable withdrawal is treated as if you get £20,000 every month, pushing much of it into higher rates.
Which form to use
- P55: you took part of your pension and won't take more this tax year
- P53Z: you emptied the pot and have other taxable income
- P50Z: you emptied the pot and have no other taxable income
If you file Self Assessment, you can let the return calculate the refund instead.
Plan the next withdrawal
Once a correct code is issued, later payments are taxed normally. Spreading withdrawals over tax years can keep more of the income in the basic rate band.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Taking a large first withdrawal without expecting emergency tax
- Using the wrong reclaim form for your situation
- Assuming the 25% tax-free part was taxed
- Taking more taxable income in one year than you need
What to do next
- Check the tax deducted on your withdrawal statement
- Choose P55, P53Z or P50Z depending on your situation
- Submit the form online with your pension details
- Plan future withdrawals across tax years
Frequently asked questions
Is the 25% tax-free part affected?
No. The tax-free element is paid without tax; emergency tax affects only the taxable part.
Will HMRC refund it automatically?
Sometimes, at the end of the tax year, but claiming with the right form is usually faster.
Do I need Self Assessment after a pension withdrawal?
Not necessarily. Many people only need the refund form, unless they have other untaxed income.
Can I avoid emergency tax completely?
Taking a small first withdrawal can get a correct tax code in place before larger payments, which reduces the risk.
Try a free calculator
- Pension Tax Relief calculator: See how much the government adds to your pension pot.
- UK Income Tax calculator: Detailed breakdown of your annual UK income tax bands.
Related guides
- State Pension on Self Assessment: Why Bank Payments May Not Be the Right Figure
- Pension Contributions and Adjusted Net Income: What to Tell Your Accountant
- Claiming a Tax Refund After Leaving a Job Mid-Year
- Pensions and Inheritance Tax From April 2027: What Changes
Living abroad with UK income?
- UK tax return for expats in Spain
- UK tax return for expats in Ireland
- UK tax return for expats in France
- UK tax returns for British expats in every country
Local tax return accountants
- Tax return accountant in Bury
- Tax return accountant in Wakefield
- Tax return accountant in Worcester
- All North West areas
- All Yorkshire and the North East areas
- All Midlands areas
Get help with this
If this applies to you, a TaxSimba accountant can prepare and file your return. See Pensioner tax returns.
